O'Toole Atwell, PC Serving Clients In Texas & Colorado For OVER 20 Years
Business & Commercial Litigation
Phone 512-475-4740
Our Practice Areas

Startup reveals problems with intellectual property law

After a Texas jury awarded $706 million to a housing data analytics startup based on claims of trade secret theft, major vulnerabilities were found in policies related to intellectual property law. Released information showed that the startup was distorting the facts of the case and misleading jurors. The case involved the use of the plaintiff's Automated Valuation Model, or AVM, a technology that's widely used in the online real estate industry.

Industry experts believe that current IP law is flawed partly because the plaintiff in this case was able to win its suit purely based on emotional appeals. Reports show that the company used no sales or revenue information to show that its AVM was worth hundreds of millions of dollars, instead relying on deception, lies and collusion to influence the jury. Whistle blowers from the plaintiff reported that the plaintiff had taken extensive action to hide the fact that their AVM didn't even work.

While this case is currently being appealed, the initial result is likely to spur many companies into filing lawsuits despite having dubious claims. Parties with these types of suits are known for shopping around for friendly courts and judges that appear to have lax standards. Nearly half of all patent cases in the United States are filed in the District Court for the Eastern District of Texas because it has a history of favoring plaintiffs.

Companies involved in business litigation related to intellectual property may want representation from a firm with a focus on business law. Whether the client is a plaintiff or defendant, it's the responsibility of the lawyers involved to stay as up to date on intellectual property law and cases as possible. An attorney may strive to solve even the most complicated disputes while keeping costs as contained as possible.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
5 Star Review

Passionate, professional, and caring! Brian did a great job representing me!
Jana ODonnell

  • Super Lawyers Brian J. O'Toole | SuperLawyers.com
  • Board Certified Texas Board of Legal Specialization | Brian J. O'Toole - Civil Trial Law
  • Austin Bar Association
  • Texas Bar Foundation
  • Supreme Court of the State of Texas
  • United States District Court | District of Colorado
Email O’Toole Atwell, PC

Make Your Appointment Today

Our main office is located in Austin, Texas, and we serve clients throughout Texas and Colorado. Contact us today at 512-475-4740 or online to find out how we can put personalized service to work for you in your legal matter.

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

O'Toole Atwell, PC
919 Congress Avenue, Suite 535
Austin, TX 78701

Phone: 512-476-4740
Fax: 512-476-1228
Austin Law Office Map